ALL complaints against a
former Bishop of Lewes, the Rt Revd Wallace Benn, under the
Clergy Discipline Measure, have been dismissed, it was announced on
Tuesday.
In a statement, Bishop
Benn denounced "misconceived and unjustified" efforts by the
safeguarding advisory group of the diocese of Chichester to bring
complaints against him. He named two complainants: the chairman of
the group, Keith Akerman, and the diocesan safeguarding adviser,
Colin Perkins. Bishop Benn said that he had been the victim of a
"one-sided and unjust process of trial by media . . . orchestrated
by unknown people with, it seems, no interest in the truth or the
ministry of the Church".
In November 2011, the
diocese of Chichester confirmed that the group had complained to
the Archbishop of Canterbury about Bishop Benn (News, 18 November, 2011).
When Bishop Benn retired in 2012, the charges were unresolved (News, 26
October).
The complaints related to
the handling of the case of Robert Coles, a former parish priest
who in February was sentenced to eight years in prison after
pleading guilty to 11 sex offences against three young boys. The
complainants argued that Bishop Benn should have passed information
that he possessed about Mr Coles's conduct to the police. Bishop
Benn has maintained that this was the responsibility of the
diocesan child-protection adviser (News, 22
February).
On Tuesday, Bishop Benn
said: "As of 10 May 2013, all complaints against me under the
Clergy Discipline Measure have come to an end without any
misconduct of any kind having been established. No complaint
against me has been allowed to proceed beyond the preliminary
stages of the process."
The complaints had been
considered by the Archbishop of York and the President of
Tribunals, Lord Justice Mummery. Some of the complaints had been
dismissed on their merits, and the rest on the basis that "they
have been made outside the time allowed under the Clergy Discipline
Measure and where no good grounds exist for any extension of
time."
Bishop Benn's statement
is largely devoted to rebuking "attempts which have been made to
cast me in the role of a scapegoat". Noting that, after receiving
advice, he had declined to comment in the press, he said that it
was a "matter of deep regret" that information about the
complaints, "much of it partial and inaccurate", had been
"repeatedly" leaked. This had led to "repeatedly unfair media
reporting".
Bishop Benn referred to a
private letter from the Bishop of Chichester, Dr Martin Warner, to
a survivor of child abuse, in which the Bishop spoke of "deception
and cover-up" and "ineptitude and irresponsible lack of
professionalism" in the Church's handling of Roy Cotton (News, 26 April).
Dr Warner had confirmed to Bishop Benn that he was not referring to
"me or any conduct on my part".
The case of Mr Cotton was
one of the issues explored by Baroness Butler-Sloss (News, 27 May, 2011), whose
report concluded that, across the diocese, there had been "a lack
of understanding of the seriousness of historic child abuse". It
said that senior clergy, including bishops, "were slow to act on
the information available to them and to assess the potential risk
to children".
In 2011, Bishop Benn and
the then Bishop of Chichester, Dr John Hind, apologised for "any
past mistakes which may have left children vulnerable and which may
have more recently made victims feel that they have not been taken
seriously". They also apologised for "weaknesses in our
procedures".
Bishop Benn said on
Tuesday: "The actions of clergy who have engaged in the abuse of
children appal me, and the ongoing effect on survivors is of the
highest concern to me. Throughout my time as Bishop of Lewes, I
have at all times tried to assist the diocese to deal appropriately
with safeguarding issues. I have also welcomed and given my full
support to the efforts made and being made to improve the practices
and procedures within the diocese for safeguarding children and
vulnerable adults.
"But none of what has
happened in the past can justify the attempts which have been made
to cast me in the role of a scapegoat without regard to where the
truth lies and where the blame ought to lie."
On Wednesday, Dr Warner
said that the motivation of the members of the safeguarding group
who made the complaints was "to indicate to survivors and their
families complete commitment to a thorough and transparent
investigation . . . The Church's procedures must be seen as
providing adequate and clear evidence of accountability in
safeguarding matters."
He hoped that the
findings of archiepiscopal Visitation (
News, 24 August 2012) would "influence the ongoing national
review of the Clergy Discipline Measure system to ensure the
adequacy of these procedures in providing reassurance to victims,
survivors and the general public that this accountability is in
place".
Dr Warner expressed "gratitude to all those involved in this
case, the diocesan safeguarding advisory group, and the outstanding
commitment of Colin Perkins, the diocesan safeguarding adviser and
his team, for all they have done to move diocesan safeguarding
towards the standards that the communities we serve and our
statutory partners rightly expect."
Three abusers sentenced
THE sentencing of two men found guilty of child
sex-abuse offences was welcomed by the Bishop of Chichester, Dr
Martin Warner, on Thursday of last week.
Last month, the Revd Keith Wilkie Denford, from
Shoreham, who was the Vicar of St John's, Burgess Hill, West
Sussex, from 1985 to 1990, was found guilty on three charges of
indecently assaulting two boys (News, 12 April). Michael
Mytton, aged 68, an organist from East Chiltington, who worked with
Mr Denford, was also found guilty on three charges.
On Thursday of last week at Hove Crown Court, Judge
Paul Tain sentenced Mr Denford to 18 months in prison. Mr Mytton
was sentenced to nine months in prison, suspended for two
years.
Dr Warner said: "The crimes committed by Mr Denford
and Mr Mytton were not reported to the diocese of Chichester prior
to 2011. Notification of the serious allegations against these two
men we had formerly trusted was the result of our working
relationship with Sussex Police and the local authority. This
indicates the vital importance of an inter-agency approach to
safeguarding. . .
"Over and above that, however, we hope that today will
mark a milestone for the survivors who have had to live through
this trial. To them we offer an unreserved apology and an assurance
that we have heard and we believe the terrible story they have had
to tell."
Carlisle priest jailed
A priest aged 70, the Revd Andrew Folks, who retired
five years ago, was jailed for eight months at Carlisle Crown Court
on Tuesday of last week after pleading guilty to child sex-abuse
offences. He was an NSM in Langdale when the abuse took place. He
pleaded guilty to a charge of attempting to indecently assault a
boy of 15. He had previously pleaded guilty to one charge of
indecent assault.