TWO weeks ago, Angela Tilby suggested a new focus of mission:
"Here's an idea. Credit unions make a real difference to those who
are on the edge of survival. . . If . . . the Church facilitated a
network of credit unions, it could put the loan sharks out of
business" (Comment, 19 July).
The Archbishop of Canterbury's attack on Wonga six days later was
not made, of course, in response to her suggestion. It dated from
an interview he had given at the start of last month, which, in
turn, stemmed from his experience of credit unions in his former
diocese of Durham. Such a coincidence, however, is the sort of
thing that happens when an idea's time has come.
The reaction in the press (Andrew Brown, Press) might
be put down to the honeymoon period that Archbishop Welby is still
enjoying. But it appears to be more than this: an instant
recognition that this was fitting work for the Church to be doing.
It did not hurt that this is the message that Pope Francis has been
promoting since his election; nor that Archbishop Welby had
expressed himself so well. Church commentary on society's ills can
all too often sound like a monotonous lament. By contrast, the
Archbishop made a direct challenge to a named competitor,
good-natured but with a frisson borrowed from price-comparison
advertising. And his remarks were grounded in practical action or,
at least, seemed to be. It was this that enabled him to ride out
the embarrassment of discovering that church funds had gone into
setting Wonga up, albeit indirectly.
The only people discomfited were the church officials who were
asked to come up with all the facts, figures, and examples of the
Church's supposed credit-union activity. What they really wanted to
do was explain the nature of prophecy - that it involves speaking
about something that has not yet come to pass. The key element here
is the enthusiasm with which the idea has been received by church
people. Relieved to get away from internal wrangles, and flattered
by outside approval, many are willing to pitch into this good work.
It is vital that such an opportunity to convert good will into
action is not lost.
The first requirement is professionalism. Wonga will not be
worried by two of the faithful in a church hall with the PCC's
cashbox. To help people in a crisis takes speed and efficiency;
compassion, yes, but translated into practical support, such as
online money transfers and debt counselling. It is good for the
Church to realise its need for partnerships with those already
working in this field, many of them secular bodies. These are
high-street operations, competing not only with the payday lenders,
but with the banks. There is an idea that Archbishop Welby might go
for.